PINKBIKE FIELD TEST
We Are One Arrival SP2
Words by Matt Beer, photography by Tom RichardsWhen We Are One teased us with sneak peeks of what looked to be a frame mold, we knew we had to get our hands on one. It's hard to talk about anything that We Are One builds without mentioning their devotion to sourcing materials as locally as possible. Their new bike, aimed at the enduro market, the Arrival, sings the same tune. Everything from the hardware and paint to the carbon sheets is sourced from within a five hundred mile radius.
Their first foray into frame building encompasses a wide array riding styles. It's ready to smash or dash. The 152mm of rear wheel travel and 160mm fork are aggressive enough to take on Enduro World Series races, but won't shy away from backcountry sufferfests.
Arrival Details • Travel: 160 mm front / 152 mm rear
• Wheel size: 29”
• Hub spacing: 157 mm
• Head angle: 64°
• Seat tube angle: 77°
• Reach: 475 mm (SZ2)
• Chainstay length: 437 mm
• Sizes: SZ1, SZ2, SZ3
• Weight: 32.04 lb / 14.53 kg (w/ control tires)
• Price: $8,899 USD
•
weareonecomposites.com This dual link, full carbon frame is purpose built around 29" wheels only, without any geometry or kinematic adjustments. In other words, there are no compromises between a steep seat angle or a slack head tube and the suspension has been tirelessly tested and tuned.
We Are One have also jumped on the size naming bandwagon. Since the field test took place, the naming has been changed from M/L to SZ2, but the reach remains the same at 475 mm. They also paused the start button on what would be a SZ4 frame, which we mentioned in the bike introduction. Currently, there are three sizes fitting riders from 5’3” to 6’4”, which seems like a bit of a stretch for those on opposite ends of the height spectrum. Reach numbers are traditional though, starting at 450 mm for a SZ1 and growing 25 mm per size to 500 mm for the SZ3.
For the SZ2 and SZ3, there are two options for dropper post length. Our SZ2 bike was equipped with a 170 mm dropper, which left 25 mm between the top of the seat clamp and the bottom of the post collar when fully inserted. I never experienced any clearance issues, but that middle rocker link pivot interrupts the seat post insertion depth, which could pose an issue for riders with a shorter inseam or different descending position.
Up front, there was a 100 mm head tube and 37 mm BB drop, creating a short stack height and aggressive, forward riding position. Henry and I both found ourselves using all 20 mm of spacers under the stem and swapping the 25 mm rise bar out for a 35 mm.
The smaller 185 mm x 55 mm trunnion mount rear shock is advised to set at 23% sag, so you won't be kicking rocks and that keeps the anti-squat in the zone for transmitting maximum watts. For my 73 kg weight, I did have to run 240 PSI in the Float X2, which might leave heavier riders maxing out the 350 PSI pressure limit.
Geometry such as a 64º head tube and a 77º effective seat tube angle are fairly standard these days, but the Arrival is versatile and doesn’t hold back in rowdy terrain. The chainstays do grow proportionately from 437 mm on the SZ1 and SZ2 frames, to 441 mm on the SZ3.
Other attributes of the frame are double row bearings on all pivots, which are housed in the links, not the carbon, a threaded BB, and… gasp, Superboost rear hub spacing. I'm not sure why this is such a heated topic, because the bike comes with its own premium wheels. This spec reduces wear on the larger cogs by keeping the chain straighter on that wide hub and pairs with a narrower 52 mm chainline.
Inside the beautifully finished raw to Cerakote matte finish frame are foam insulating tubes for the housings. This method superseded guided internal routing for one reason: quality carbon compaction. Internal guides can prohibit compaction when molding the carbon and leave voids, which can pose as stress rise areas.
On the topic of workmanship, all of the fixtures and threaded axles feed into replaceable, keyed alloy nuts, not the carbon, with the exception of the BB shell and proprietary brake mount. This bracket bolts straight up to a 180 mm rotor for the strongest and longest wearing design. At no surprise, the frame is backed by a manufacturing defect lifetime warranty.
What is really interesting though is their crash
repair program. We Are One offer to fix the frame without financially profiting from the service. It’s actually more expensive to fix the frame member than replacing it, which shows they are conscious of their environmental impact. They also assemble the Arrival in Kamloops without any plastic wrapping or ties and practice reusing other component manufacturers’ packaging.
For $8,899 USD, the Arrival comes with the mechanical SRAM XO1 groupset, Fox Factory suspension, Magura MT5 brakes, a Chris King headset, an SDG dropper post, and Vittoria Mazza tires. Of course, you’ll find their renowned carbon Union rims laced to Industry 9 1/1 hubs and Da Package carbon bar and alloy stem combo too.
The no holds barred build checks out at $10,999 with a full SRAM XX1 AXS wireless drivetrain and dropper post, Magura MT7 brakes, I9 Hydra hubs, and is finished with the same We Are One parts mentioned in the other build. Now that is a high entry level build price, but we are talking about premium components on a carbon frame that is made in North America.
At this time, complete bikes are the only option, but there are production plans to offer rolling chassis and Push 11/6 shock options.
ClimbingSurprise - the lightest bike of the lot was also an effective climber, both on trail and in the efficiency test. Yes, there is a climb switch, but it’s really not necessary. The bike simply went forward when you stepped on the pedals, not up and down, due to that linkage configuration. Don’t let this undermine the descending capabilities of the Arrival, as we’ll discuss those shortly. When pointed in either direction on the hill, rear wheel traction was plentiful and maintained excellent small bump performance.
You might think that the large BB drop would lead to crank strikes and clumsy navigation through tech uphill routes, but this is where the 23-25% sag suggest makes sense. I like to preach about bikes that retain their geometry, or at least front to rear balance, and the Arrival is one of them. This makes it predictable to time pedal strokes when you put the power down or lunge up stepped trail features.
I found the steep seat angle and lower bar height a benefit while climbing, and was surprised in several instances by the Arrival's ability to scale some ridiculously steep pitches. The shorter rear center made the traction limit somewhat easier to find, and I could shift my weight accordingly, all while keeping the front wheel from wandering.
Descending
Immediately, when I jumped on the Arrival, I felt like both my contact points; hands and feet, were close to the ground, as if I was on a snappy, slalom bike. At slower warm up speeds it was noticeably lighter and more agile, like the YT, compared to the bigger bruisers in the fleet. I was anxious to throw this thing into some high speed berms, but also had some initial reservations of how the lesser travel and low body position would pan out on the steeper, rougher runs. Did we mention how fast the trails are at Sun Peaks?
I have to say, I was blown away with the Arrival’s capability on serious downhill tracks. Of course, the limit was a finer balance at race pace than on the longer travel and lengthy wheelbase of the Range and Force Carbon, but that suspension really gave the Arrival some muscle. There was no shortage of stability through heavy compressions and brake bumps, which contributed to confidence levels.
In those heavy braking zones, the bike remained active and the dual-link suspension didn’t squat or firm up the suspension. I was genuinely impressed with how that smaller rear shock did everything so well, including those sections of rumble-stripped singletrack. The Float X2 aided the right amount of kinematic progression. No, it’s not a high pivot, but the axle path seemed to move the wheel out of the way without using much travel. The drivetrain feedback was minimal, both in terms of pedal kickback and noise.
The only place I noticed a bit of feedback was at slower speeds on technical single track over roots, but I think this was more about my level of engagement and body positioning. The Arrival definitely rewards a rider that charges.
While it can chase the welterweight enduro bikes down raw downhill tracks, there is a limit. It still has elements that keep it hunkered down on your line, but you’re asking a lot from 152 mm of travel to bomb full-on downhill tracks. It is more demanding to ride at those speeds over longer sections of physical trail, but it can be done with a bit more focus and skill.
When Mike Levy posed the question, “What bike would you chose for an EWS season?”, I was torn between the Arrival and the Specialized Enduro. The main differentiator would be the fatigue factor. With the Arrival’s shorter travel and speed-hungry, attack character it might be more physical on longer race stages. The 170mm front and rear travel Enduro does slightly give up the ability to duck and weave in tighter corners, which the Arrival loves and our timed testing proved. Otherwise, both bikes possess contemporary geometry and respectable weights, making them top candidates for enduro racing.
If you had to give me one bike to go ride anywhere on the planet, I’d pack my bags and box up an Arrival. There would be very little terrain that I would shy away from onboard this bike. Its all-encompassing suspension attributes and geometry tackle every type of trail well. It has that rally car responsiveness that would suit riding destinations with ripping, technical single track, topped with plenty of corners and jumps to slay; Bellingham, WA, Bromont, QC, and of course Kamloops, BC are a few regions that come to mind. The Arrival is a do-it-all enduro bike that left us impressed with its eagerness to keep up with some longer travel bikes.
Please do not allow Levy to ever make that expression on camera again.
youtu.be/_4lDASeWsFg?t=60s
I think it’s safe to say he is not muted
gfycat.com/focusedzigzagasianelephant
Next time have some beers like they do on Beta bike test (AKA- Bible bike test) sit or stand some distance apart so its more genuine and less fickle with some attitude.
Jus sayn
I love that it’s designed and built in North America… and that by itself may be enough for me to get over the appearance.
I bought berries today - I chose the local ones over the ones from Mexico. They were more expensive. I bought salmon and halibut too - chose the fresh caught in BC stuff over the frozen imported option. More expensive.
I have a We Are One Arrival - SZ2 / SP1 / Push 11.6 on order - I could not be more excited for a bike. I am stoked to support all the individuals in Kamloops that make this possible. Please keep doing what you are doing.
ps... My Ibis is for sale
I was able to place the order through my local bike shop, and after a few weeks they called to check on on the status.
My LBS owner just called WAO's number, and someone picked up the phone on the 2nd ring. When the bike shop owner asked when they thought my wheels would ship, it was clear that the WAO employee just set the phone down, and shouted over his shoulder: "How, how are those Insiders headed to Moscow coming along? ... No, Moscow Idaho ... Ok, great." Then picked up the phone and said, "They're almost done. Should have them out next week."
No, "We'll check with the factory and get back to you." No, "Oh, on a boat somewhere." Just, "We're working on them, right over there."
The Arrival isn't the right bike for me, but something would have to change drastically if I ever bought another wheelset from a different manufacturer.
-Comment section : yeti expensive shit fu&k rich daddy dentist a*sholes ….
-Pink bike reviews Canadian made we are one made just down the street BUT COST $10000…
-comment section : great bike . Way to go , so pretty , here are 10 reasons why who ever dared saying it’s expensive is an ignorant a*shole …
The value-to-cost ratio of their wheels is one of the reasons I’m surprised at the price of this bike. They built a reputation on a solid product for a reasonable price, and then they come out with a really expensive bike. To be clear, I don’t begrudge them the price, but I’ll likely never own one. It’s just too expensive for me. Maybe it’s the cost of North American manufacturing, but they’ve been doing a great job of competitive pricing for their wheels. Why does the complete bike cost so much in comparison?
Also, I think you gotta mention Guerilla Gravity is doing their manufacturing in Colorado, and their top-of-the-line Enduro bike is much more cost effective.
I want to bring up one other thing…service. Memphis and crew have taken care of me like I am one of their own. My Insiders are currently being rebuilt by WAO, and I am riding my old Agents in the meantime. The level of service from these guys, even through COVID, has been exceptional. I would be an idiot to ever stray from something this good.
My Druid has a story behind it too. It was Dustin’s frame. He gave it up so I could buy it, and he bought a gloss moss instead. First production run. Third huge season on it.
That said, I am thinking hard about this one. I may have to beg and grovel to see if a large might turn up somewhere…Dustin? I may have to bribe my banker too…
Is it pretty good? Probably yes. But it's also is it $ 3.000 more expensive than the Capra, Force and Spire. Consequently, one would have to ask if it is also $ 3.000 better than those. And most likely, it is not.
They did not pay a manufacturer in Asian to build their design.
They make some of the best rims on the planet
They are not "beginners"...
A TR Sentinel XO1 (which is a direct comparable) is $7200 without carbon wheels.
WA1 to all other bike brands in North America...Hold our collective beer!!!!
The real apples-to-apples comparison will be when Guerilla Gravity releases their "Fully Revved" (all-carbon including the rear triangle) Gnarvana. Somehow those damned Coloradans have so-far managed to keep their pricing for hand-made-in-the-USA carbon bikes in-line with the lower-end of overseas frames. E.g., their full-Carbon 120/130mm Trail Pistol is $6,100 for an X01 build, and $5,200 for a GX build.
I don't begrudge anyone who is willing to pay more for a WAO made-in-Canada bike, in fact, I can think of lots of worse ways to use your money. But you are definitely paying a premium.
But a 0.3 degree change? 3mm of bottom bracket height change? Get lost with that junk.
Headtube adjustment takes 5 minutes.
Also note that the stumpy evo S4 has identical geometry as their test bike . I don’t think the Stumpy suspension is as dialed as WAO. But much cheaper.
It's not to change just geometry, but frame progressivity to suit a wider variety of rider's styles and/or terrain. Especially with coils, a way to fine tune frame progressivity (and for air, less reliance on tokens which has positives) is a great free tool. It's 0 additional work/maintenance, you change it to where you want it acts like any pivot bolt. Not a must have for your next bike but an odd thing to bemoan.
It would be like complaining Fox/Rockshox have too many token sizes. There's a reason Cascade Components don't make an aftermarket link for Rocky Mountain: "they're already done it [with the Ride-9]", though Rocky's is adjustable both ways (more or less progressive) and with finer steps. youtu.be/LX0nZjHKvcM?t=245
Still, for me, the idea of a bunch of different settings and holes, some of which can definitely hurt the bike's performance more than help it, isn't what I want to see. I want a bike that's made to work well with whatever shock it comes with, and that shock should have more than enough scope for tuning progressivity via volume spacers. Obviously, if you're a really heavy person or a very light person, you're out of the ideal range, but I'll argue all day long that we don't need that sort of adjustment and that at least 95% (pulled that straight out of my ass haha) never touch it more than once, if at all.
The argument that that 95% (out of ass estimate haha) of riders never touch it could be said for most suspension settings and even tokens. To quote the great Henry Quinney "This idea that we should be at the whims of the most mechanically inept is bizarre.".
Excellent first bike, but I’ll be eagerly awaiting V2 or 3 and some more travel options. I really, really hope they grow this into a portfolio of frame-only options and get away from using the same front triangle for various models. Would love for my money to go a company like WR1.
*I would like to submit the following bikes for consideration as ‘uglier’ - Marin Wolf Ridge (finally discontinued after 2020) - - Eminent Cycles ‘MT 29’ - Niner Rip 9 (current) - Esker FS Bikes - and last but NOT least, the structure cycles SCW1
I would also like to hear a direct comparison between the WAO and the Ripmo. (And maybe throw in last year’s PB bike of the year, the Stumpy Evo)
But, I’m assuming doing this I’ll need the different linkages, different shocks, and I know different forks. It’s an awesome idea and when not in use those forks and shocks become decorative art in the house.
m.pinkbike.com/news/review-marin-mount-vision-9.html
Yes the TR Sentinel is an almost identical bike.
Simple !
Martin Maes seems to prefer the 36...
m.pinkbike.com/news/bike-check-martin-maes-gt-force-is-not-ordinary.html
Actually, with the proliferation of ebikes, that tech may never come. That’s probably one of the reasons the industry loves ebikes so much. They don’t have to stress about weight.
Look, I love my 33lbs Enduro - it RIPS, but the thing is a pig and I really do wish it was about 3 lbs lighter. I also get to experience the opposite end of the spectrum with a 23lbs Epic Evo and seriously - light bikes are so much fun up AND down.
Either that or let manufacturers drop lifetime warranties so they can build less durable bikes which will also be lighter.
I think you get my point, there are trade offs to be made. We can't have everything and choices are being made now to make bikes more durable. In order to accomplish that things have gotten heavier. Add on the fact that a lot of riders are riding significantly steeper/rougher trails. Our local zone would not have been out of place as a WC DH stop ten years ago. It is that steep and rough, yet we are now pedaling to the top on bikes that are probably faster than what they used to race.
With EXO/EXO+ tires, you’d be looking at under 31lbs for the WAO - and getting a lot of punctures if riding the bike up to its potential.
It is really hard to imagine shedding much weight on bikes in this category without making them less capable.
Trail bikes and ‘downcountry’ bikes… well that’s another story.
Do you really need a Zeb 38, or will a 160mm Pike do just fine?
Do you really need double down casings on both (or any) tires, or can you get by with lighter casings?
Stuff like that. Maybe the answer is yes, you need it, but I think a lot of people are riding around on overbuilt bikes.
Also, do yourself a favor and buy yourself some nice wheels. They tend to be lighter and snappier in a place where it really counts.
As far as the chain guide, it’s just an insurance policy for a failed clutch (or forgot to turn it back on), or some other rare freakish event that can happen at very high speeds on rough terrain, think UPS in Moab. Also, weight penalty of the chain guide is tiny when adding to a bash guard.
I think you mean chain line. 52mm Q-factor is impossible, at least with a 73mm BB she'll...
Any chance there will be a comparison to the Spesh Enduro control bike? Will be interesting seeing how it was last years favourite.
And my first comment should of read:
"Any chance there will be a comparison to the Spesh Enduro control bike? Will be interesting seeing how last years favorite stacks up".
Could be a good thing to do an scale chart/s (as Hambini does ;-) ) to situate the bike and its competitors based in its his category (define by its brand and Pinkbike staff - XC, ¿back country?, Trail, All Mountain, DH, Freeride) and its capability (Enduro Race, Bike Park, etc...), or tag them to do a fast search...
Guess where those suppliers get most of their stuff from..
I am all for trying to buy USA/Canada made gear, but that is a fair bit of dental work to perform...
Sensitive snowflake dentists around here...lol
I didnt actually think it was salty dentists downvoting me...
All of the bikes use high-end suspension that's comparable, which is the most important thing. A bike's drivetrain has very little effect on the outcome or how it performs as a whole.
I have never owned a Knolly, not a fanboy, I just find it interesting...
Yeah, we need more shock-destroying yokes. Innovation!!!
Purpose
To be ridden wherever you want.
Thank you for your insight into the world of all mountain and big trail bikes. A pleasure to read before my morning coffee.